Please feel free to e-mail this article to a friend, a principal, a parent, a colleague, a teacher librarian, a college professor, a poet, a magician, a vendor, an artist, a juggler, a student, a news reporter or anyone you think might enjoy it.

 From Now On
The Educational Technology Journal


 Vol 8|No 8|May|1999

 

 

 

Since when is Adult a dirty word?

 

by Jamie McKenzie

(About the Author)

    Note (June 11, 1999): Since this article was published in May, it appears that SurfWatch has discontinued the practice of automatically blocking sites using the file names "adult.html" and "adult.htm." While there has been no formal acknowledgement of wrong doing or defamation of character by SurfWatch, From Now On takes pride in seeing the word "adult" restored to common usage.

Even though the filtering of information by third parties is often represented as a gift to children . . . as some act of decency in an indecent world, some members of the filtering industry embrace and commit indecencies of their own.
A SL@P is an electronic insult - an unfounded and defamatory label applied to a Web page without looking.

A SL@PPER is a company which indulges in indiscriminate SL@PPING without regard to the damage done to the victims of SL@P.

For other new forms of electronic misconduct, see SPAM, Telephone Slamming and SCAM.

 
  • Some filters block perfectly legitimate information by relying upon crude word searching strategies which block articles on adult learning and breast cancer.
  • These filters may defame the character of some individuals and information providers. They often announce that a site is blocked because it contains "sexually explicit" material even when no such material is present and they have not taken the time to check the content before characterizing it falsely.
  • It appears that some filtering companies may insult first by blocking most sites which contain the file name "adult.html" until someone complains. They only retreat and apologize after being "caught in the act." They systematically defame and then retreat, damaging hundreds and thousands of reputations as a matter of course.
  • We are seeing broad-based, wide brush attacks on the character of the electronic community with the disregard for individuals and providers we normally associate with Internet Spammers. They have invented a new form of insult . . . the electronic smear campaign . . . the SL@P.

A SL@P is an electronic insult - an unfounded and defamatory label applied to a Web page without looking at it to check its contents. It is an electronic rumor, a digital dismissal, a gratuitous and indecent assault on the reputation of an unknown person.

A SL@PPER is a company which indulges in indiscriminate SL@PPING without regard to the damage done to the victims of SL@P.

For other new forms of electronic misconduct, see SPAM, Telephone Slamming and SCAM.

An article on adult learning appearing here at From Now On was blocked by SurfWatch during April. Even though it contained no sexually explicit material, clients of SurfWatch were told that the article was blocked for that reason.

(click here to see how SurfWatch characterized the article on one From Now On site even as recently as May 9, 1999). Please remember that this author filled out their review form for both sites on April 23 and at the time this article was published on May 12 they had only responded to the one which was named in the listserv message.

(click here to read the blocked article http://staffdevelop.org/adult.html)

This article you are reading right now was also blocked by SurfWatch before it was even published. They evidently block new files named with adult.html until they are asked to desist.

(click here to see how SurfWatch characterized this article as "sexually explicit on May 9, 1999, before it had even been posted on the Web.)

If you are worried about your own site or other sites being unfairly characterized, you may test them by visiting http://www1.surfwatch.com/testasite/body.html

No Warning

A content provider or individual could be maligned on a daily basis for weeks and weeks without knowing that damage was being done and without knowing how many people had been erroneously told that they were harboring sexually explicit material.

On April 23, a technology director e-mailed From Now On complaining that she could not reach an article written about adult learning.

(click here to read her e-mail message - name withheld)

When the article was checked on April 23rd at http://www.surfwatch.com SurfWatch blocked it at both From Now On addresses (fno.org and fromnowon.org) stating that it was blocked for "sexually explicit material."

On this same page they offer a form to fill out if you think their characterization is unjust and should be reviewed. I filled out the form for both addresses and heard nothing back until May 5. The May 5 note from SurfWatch resulted, evidently, when someone e-mailed a copy of my listserv posting to LM_NET complaining about the situation. Filling out their forms did no good. Complaining to 25,000 librarians caught their attention.

(click here for a copy of the belated SurfWatch response and apology)

After a week of no action and no response from SurfWatch, I asked my attorney to take legal action and contacted both the ACLU and the press.

Arbitrary, Capricious and Irresponsible

This approach to blocking content is arbitrary, capricious and irresponsible. It apparently relies upon clues like the file name "adult.html" to filter and then label pages as "sexually explicit" without actually examining their content. If they were simply blocking the site, it would be one kind of damage, but they go a step further by labeling the content erroneously as "sexually explicit." This is defamation of character and false.

We are witnessing an industry which uses crude measures to deliver "information security" and applies a standard that a page or a site is "guilty until proven innocent."

List of the Falsely Accused

The following 32 Web pages were blocked by SurfWatch for what they claimed was "sexually explicit material" when they were checked at the SurfWatch site during the week of May 10. None of them contained "sexually explicit material" as far as this author can tell. Visit and judge for yourself (if you do not have SurfWatch installed).

Update (May 21): Surfwatch stopped blocking FNO pages and removed the explicit sexual material label.

Please notice the large number of respectable organizations SL@PPED in this manner.

Update (May 21): Surfwatch stopped blocking these pages once FNO notified these sites that they had been blocked and published the list in this article.

Blocked! 5/10/99 National Cancer Institute - Hodgkin's Disease Unblocked by 5/21/99

Very useful information from the Federal government for cancer patients which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://rex.nci.nih.gov/INFO_CANCER/ADULT_HODGKNS.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Helping Your Child Use the Library US ED Dept Unblocked by 5/21/99

US Department of Education Office of Educational Research and Improvement - an article for parents which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://ericps.crc.uiuc.edu/npin/respar/texts/helping/library/adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Literacy Council of Alaska Unblocked by 5/21/99

A list of Adult Literacy resources which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://zorba.uafadm.alaska.edu/fairnet/volops/agencies/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Lawrence (KS) Parks and Recreation:
ADULT SPORTS (1999 WinterSpring)
Unblocked by 5/21/99

A schedule of recreational activities which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://zorba.uafadm.alaska.edu/fairnet/volops/agencies/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Sea Scouting: Sea Scouter's Training Award Unblocked by 5/21/99
Page describing how to become an adult scout leader which contains no sexually explicit material.
 
http://www.sea.scouter.com/for_leaders/adult_recognition/adult-award.html
Blocked! 5/10/99 Queensland University for Technology - Adult and Workplace Educators Unblocked by 5/21/99

A page outlining a range of Adult and Workplace Education programs offered by the University which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://www.qut.edu.au/pubs/contprofed/adult/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 The Albany (Oregon) Public Library - Adult Services Unblocked by 5/21/99

A page outlining a range of Adult programs offered by the Library which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://www.ci.albany.or.us/pages/library/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 The Southern Pine Beetle Adult Unblocked by 5/21/99

A high quality photograph of an adult beetle, part of a biology site, with no apparent sexually explicit material.

http://everest.ento.vt.edu/~salom/SPBbiology/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 South Park Church Adult Ministries Unblocked by 5/21/99

A page from a church in Park Ridge, Illinois which contains no sexually explicit material.

http://www.park-ridge.il.us/spchurch/frames/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 HyperText Psychology - GROWTH/Adult Unblocked by 5/21/99

Materials for a Wayne State - The College of Science - psychology course which contain no sexually explicit material.

http://www.science.wayne.edu/~wpoff/cor/gro/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Royal Victoria Hospital Psychology Department Adult Services Unblocked by 5/21/99

Hospital services which contain no sexually explicit material.

http://www.psych.mcgill.ca/labs/rvh/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Joy of Living - Adult Bible Studies Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.joyofliving.org/html/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Hackley Public Library links to sites of interest to adults Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.muskegon.k12.mi.us/library/adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Penn State's College of Health and Human Development - Graduate Study in Adult Development and Aging Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.hhdev.psu.edu/hdfs/Grad/adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Oregon Health Division : Adult Immunization Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/ccfh/imm/adults/adultimm.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 adult lamprey Unblocked by 5/21/99

This sea lamprey page is part of a larger project about environmental issue pertaining to Hamilton Harbour in conjunction with McMaster University's Biology Dept.

http://www.science.mcmaster.ca/Biology/Harbour
/SPECIES/SEALAMP/ADULT.HTM

Blocked! 5/10/99 Cancer Support Services - Colorado HealthNet Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.coloradohealthnet.org/cancer/support/css_adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 St. Charles Library - Adult Services Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.chicago.avenew.com/comnity/stcharls/library/ADULT.HTM

Blocked! 5/10/99 The University of Western Australia Psychology: Blink Reflex in Adults Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.psy.uwa.edu.au/user/linda/biglab/adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Pacific Northwest College of Art C.E. Adult Classes Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.pnca.edu/htmls/pro/ce/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 SPRINGFIELD ADULT BASIC AND LITERACY EDUCATION Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.wittenberg.edu/witt/commservice/agency/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Internet Master - The Adult Learner Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://outreach.missouri.edu/ne-imaster/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Auburn University Programs in Adult Education Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://webserv.duc.auburn.edu/academic/education/ved/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 adult Student Resource Center Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://jcweb.gmu.edu/maps/pages/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 LISTING OF IMPAIRMENTS - Oregon Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.ohsu.edu/cliniweb/disability/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 INSTITUTE FOR NEUROLOGY AND NEUROSURGERY
AT THE BETH ISRAEL MEDICAL CENTER - Chemotherapy and Radiotherapy for Brain and Spinal Cord Tumors
Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://nyneurosurgery.org/inn/tumor/chemotherapy/adult.htm

Blocked! 5/10/99 Suffolk University Education and Human Services Department - Graduate Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.cas.suffolk.edu/ehs/graduate/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 MELON -- Middletown Township Public Library Adult Programs Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.monmouth.edu/irs/library/melon/middletown/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Memphis College of Art Community Ed Adult Non-Credit Courses Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.mca.edu/comm_ed/ce_adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 The University at Albany- Learning Standards Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.albany.edu/twoyear/stwbestprac
/webintro/matrix/adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 Adult Classes Recreational Pool - University of California - Davis Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://campusrecreation.ucdavis.edu/recpool/rp_adult.html

Blocked! 5/10/99 U of Minn Dept of Surgery CVT Fellowship Program Unblocked by 5/21/99

http://www.surg.umn.edu/surg/CVTsurg/CVTheart_adult.html

Virtual Relief

While the company claims to review complaints in order to protect people and sites from unfair ratings, I filled out their forms for both of my Web sites on April 23rd and had seen no change in one of the listings 19 days later. The only blocking they removed was the one which appeared on a listserv.

Legal Relief

The electronic frontier brings with it powerful ways to communicate information, some of which are healthy and beneficial. Unfortunately, these positive advancements are offset by other new technologies which can block legitimate information and damage the reputation of hundreds and thousands of people while hiding behind the excuse that they are protecting children.

Fortunately, the court system offers injured parties the right to bring their cases before a judge and jury to demand an end to the defamatory practice and the award of damages to those whose character and Web sites have been falsely accused.

This journal has asked that SurfWatch remove all blocking of articles on the From Now On web sites and to cease and desist the defamatory practice of affixing the "sexually explicit" label where none is justified.

    Note (June 11, 1999): Since this article was published in May, SurfWatch has discontinued the practice of blocking pages at From Now On which have "adult" in the file name.

We have further requested a public apology from a high ranking company officer that may be republished in From Now On and on several educational listservs where SurfWatch clients can read it.

    Note (June 11, 1999): There has been none.

We have also insisted that SurfWatch cease the apparent practice of blocking and characterizing of Web sites simply because of file names such as "adult.html" as this is plainly discriminatory, irresponsible and potentially defamatory.

    Note (June 11, 1999): Since this article was published in May, it appears that SurfWatch has discontinued the practice of automatically blocking sites using the file names "adult.html" and "adult.htm." While there has been no formal acknowledgement of wrong doing or defamation of character by SurfWatch, From Now On takes pride in seeing the word "adult" restored to common usage.

If SurfWatch does not agree to these demands, we will proceed with legal action, including the possibility of a class action suit.

Please let us know if you have experienced problems with information being unfairly blocked by this product at your library, school, university or business site. We would also like to hear if you have been blocked unfairly from reading materials. Please send an e-mail message to the Editor at mckenzie@fno.org
and we will send a list of questions for you to consider.

Join us in putting an end to the SL@P!

Back to May Contents

Credits: The photographs were shot by Jamie McKenzie. Icons from Jay Boersma. Copyright Policy: Materials published in From Now On may be duplicated in hard copy format if unchanged in format and content for educational, nonprofit school district and university use only and may also be sent from person to person by e-mail. This copyright statement must be included. All other uses, transmissions and duplications are prohibited unless permission is granted expressly. Showing these pages remotely through frames is not permitted.
FNO is applying for formal copyright registration for articles.

From Now On Index Page